Brian Lowry

Resource

September 13, 2005

The show's debut represents a promising plunge into the darkness.

Mary Colgan

Resource

September 20, 2005

It has plenty of thrills and chills.

Diana Steenbergen

Resource

March 20, 2008

A series with a weekly horror story is intriguing, and the investigators being brothers, and on the wrong side of the law, makes it different from other programs on television.

Heather Havrilesky

Resource

September 13, 2005

The ultimate premise doesn't seem too promising, nor does the cool-guy dialogue.

Garth Franklin

Resource

September 16, 2013

I have to admit this was not one of my favorite pilots that was picked up this year, but it does have some small potential.

Emily Ashby

Resource

September 13, 2005

So many true-to-life issues surface in this series that astute viewers will see it's much more than a pretty-boy drama (although the fact that the guys aren't bad to look at is a bonus).

Matthew Gilbert

Resource

September 13, 2005

There's nothing about the central family story in 'Supernatural or its bland actors that makes it addictive. It's horror rehash that never quite takes flight.

Eric Neigher

Resource

September 13, 2005

Supernatural's shortcomings could have been mitigated were its plotlines authentically scary

Supernatural - Season 1